|

|
Why Kay Khan has to go
By Tom Mountain
Wednesday, October 13, 2004
|
|
|
Far too often, elected officials behave like dinner guests who
linger on towards midnight. You wish they'd simply pick up and leave
on their own, but it soon becomes apparent that they require not
just a polite nudge but a boot out the door. Too many enter elected
positions with the notion that they'll stay glued to their coveted
seats until the Grim Reaper pays a visit. Subtle hints are rarely
enough to send chronically entrenched politicians packing, unless
their job becomes a hopeless dead endand they have a bigger and
better political job lined up.
Such as what happened to David Cohen in the State House. Cohen backed
the wrong man for speaker in 1996, and so the victor, Tom Finneran,
took away his legislative power and sentenced him to political exile.
Say what you want about Hizzoner, at least he had the common sense
to know that his long reign as an influential state representative
was up. So with no future in the State House he bailed out and upgraded
to the mayor's office.
Kay Khan, a Newton legislator since 1994, followed the lead of Cohen
and also backed the wrong candidate for speaker. She lost, too.
Not that she had any clout to begin with. Her political fortunes
rested with former Speaker Charlie Flaherty, who was indicted; David
Cohen, who was exiled; and Ritchie Voke, who was expunged.
But unlike Cohen, who cut his losses and got out, Kay Khan lingered
on despite having no prospect of a committee chairmanship, no chance
to move up the political ranks, no real consideration for her bills
and no shred of any political clout.
Suffice it to say that since her mentor, David Cohen, jumped ship
in 1996, Kay Khan has been a political lame duck. She is now, has
been and will remain politically irrelevant. She's irrelevant to
the State Legislature, irrelevant as a representative for Newton.
Khan doesn't matter in the State House.
For 10 years, she's been doing little more than taking up space
on Beacon Hill. And it shows.
In the decade since she's been at the State House, only a handful
of the many dozens of bills she's sponsored have even made it to
the floor of the House for debate. She couldn't even muster up enough
support for something as simple as Route 128 sound barriers for
Waban. Her political stature is so low she had no role in securing
state funding for Newton North.
Khan has a zero rating with Citizens for Limited Taxation, which
means she's voted for every imaginable tax hike that came her way.
Even after her Newton constituents approved a state income tax rollback
on a statewide ballot question, she still lobbied to maintain the
tax hike.
She isn't taken seriously at the State House. Neither, for that
matter, are her Newton colleagues, Ruth Balser and Cynthia Creem.
They're all viewed for what they are - far left liberals. In a liberal
State Legislature, they're even too liberal for the liberals. They're
more in sync with the Socialist Workers Party than the mainstream
Democratic Party.
Khan has spent the last eight years wasting her time trying to oust
the House Democratic leadership and railing against a succession
of Republican governors. She's managed to alienate them all. And
in the process, she's become a political nobody to the Democrats
and a joke to the Republican governors. She's had zero political
influence on Beacon Hill - none with the governor's line of Weld,
Celucci, Swift or Romney; none with the former or current House
Democratic leadership. Her office lies in the basement of the State
House - the political basement - where she'll remain indefinitely.
At this point, Khan is about as welcome on Beacon Hill as a bag
lady at Symphony Hall.
Question: How has Kay Khan's eight year relentless hostility towards
the House Democratic leadership and all the Republican governors
benefited Newton? Answer: it hasn't. And as a result she's become
a political liability for Newton.
That's why she has to go. But like any self-indulged politician
devoid of pride, she won't leave gracefully. She needs to get booted
out. We need to vote her out. She's been so lazy on the job, she
even forgot to file her nomination papers on time in the last election.
And until now she's had at most token opposition. Those days are
over. Because of one smart, classy, dignified private citizen who
can and will matter for Newton in the State House.
Greer Tan Swiston.
Swiston is not a politician. Unlike the backroom Democratic City
Committee deals that initially brought Khan to power, Swiston is
not a political insider. She's not beholden to David Cohen. She
doesn't socialize with political lackeys like School Committee Members-for-Life
Anne Larner or Susan Heyman. She has no need to grovel before the
Newton political establishment. She's not one of them. She's a political
outsider beholden to no one.
And with the enthusiastic backing of the governor, she'll do well
by Newton.
Swiston is a progressive Republican, not a George W. conservative
Republican. She comes from that long line of altruistic progressive
Republicans which our state - and city - have been famous for. Newton
has produced some of the most acclaimed Republican leaders the state
has ever seen. Governor Christian Herter. Senator Ed Brooke. Mayor
Monte Basbas. Mayor Teddy Mann. All outstanding public servants.
All beloved politicians. All progressive Republicans. We voted for
who they were and how they represented us. Their party affiliation
was always of second nature.
Diversity, it's a theme we take seriously in Newton. And we've always
prided ourselves on being the type of maverick city that goes against
the trend. Ed Brooke was the first black U.S. Senator since Reconstruction.
Ed Brooke of Newton. He was one of us. He embodied us.
So what could today be more demonstrative of our tradition of celebrating
diversity than electing Greer Tan Swiston, an MIT-educated engineer
of Asian descent, to represent us on Beacon Hill? There's never
been a single elected Asian-American, male or female, in the State
House. Not one. It's long overdue. We could - and should - be the
first city to send the first elected Asian-American to Beacon Hill.
Swiston has the charm, intelligence and charisma to reintroduce
Newton to the State House. She'll be a crucial conduit to this Republican
governor and the next. She'll give us the political clout we'll
need on Beacon Hill, and command the respect and attention that
our current whining all female delegation is lacking. She'll be
the best political asset for Newton.
Ed Brooke started from Newton; Greer Tan Swiston could as well.
She's has all the makings of a future U.S. Senator.
Yes, she's a Republican. But so were Ed Brooke, Bill Weld and Teddy
Mann. And we were glad to vote for them.
Tom Mountain can be reached at tmount117@hotmail.com.
|